Review

In this historical narrative detailing America’s Great Migration, Wilkerson gives life to the otherwise underresearched and often overlooked movement of Black Americans fleeing the apartheid South in the hopes of finding a more free life in the Northern states. By telling the stories of three individuals — Ida Mae, George Starling, and Robert Foster — who chose to make the life-changing journey, Wilkerson takes the reader on a trip through time and space, traveling from the 1930s to present day; from the expanse of the southern country’s rolling cotton plantations to the concrete structures of the urban North.

One of the most interesting aspects of Wilkerson’s novel is the ongoing theme of individual versus group empowerment; despite partaking in a mass movement, these American protagonists see themselves as individuals making strictly individual choices. Whether out of necessity or in an effort at self-empowerment, each person’s escape from the homicidal, life-threatening realities of the south leads them into an equally violent milieu of racial injustice. While the de jure segregationist policies of the south may have prevented Black americans from achieving socioeconomic independence, the de facto northern regimes of inequality similarly thwarted migrants’ attempts at social progress.

In the face of these racially-dictated regimes of power, the migrants whose stories Wilkerson highlights manage to find a means of empowering themselves and one another, be it via urban community groups or academia. But the worlds in which they find themselves, regardless of their efforts, is one in which opportunities for social and economic growth are increasingly dictated by structural limitations imposed by a society that never addressed the multiple regimes of apartheid and exclusion on which it was built.

Wilkerson’s story, which begins in 1937 in Chickasaw County, Mississippi, ends in present day with the inaugural address of President Barack Obama in January of 2009:

Because we have tasted the bitter swill of civil war and segregation, and emerged from that dark chapter stronger and more united, we cannot help but believe that the old hatreds shall someday pass; that the lines of tribe shall soon dissolve; that, as the world grows smaller, our common humanity shall reveal itself…

The stories of Ida Mae, George Starling, and Robert Foster tell the reader exactly how close we have come to realizing this common humanity. And how much farther we have yet to go.



About the Author

Erin Brodwin
Erin Brodwin is a freelance multimedia journalist specializing in urban and environmental reporting. She currently works for the NYCity News Service, a student-powered initiative of the CUNY Graduate School of Journalism. A Southern California transplant to New York City, Erin has worked as a Student Director of the Student Sustainability Center at the University of California, San Diego, where she was instrumental in writing policy which made UCSD one of the first Fair Trade Certified campuses in the nation. Erin’s eye for design, her background in critical race and gender studies, and her passion for all things sustainable has taken her to places like the City of Los Angeles Workforce Investment Board, where she lead their Communications division, and Goodwill Industries International, where she worked as a grant writer and provided vocational services to low-income residents of East Los Angeles. Erin speaks English and Spanish and has lived and studied in Southern California, Morelia, Mexico, Tarragona, Spain, and Salvador, Brazil. She currently resides in New York City. You can view her portfolio (although it's still a work-in-progress!) at erinbrodwin.journalism.cuny.edu