ClickRally
Magazine


Culture

September 28th, 2011

Will smoking bans make smoking habits worse?



HookahBar

According to the American Nonsmokers’ Rights Foundation, almost 80% of Americans currently live in a municipality that bans smoking in the workplace, local bars, restaurants, and other public and private spaces. The smoking ban campaign aims to address health concerns associated with cigarettes by achieving cleaner indoor air. Some cities, like Belmont, California, have even gone as far as outlawing smoking in public outdoor spaces as well, leaving private property as the only ban-free space for smokers.

An unforeseen outcome of smoking ban policies are associated with the sharp rise in the use of hookah (also referred to as shisha or gallion). Since 2005, the quantity and demographic of hookah consumption has changed substantially — overall hookah use has jumped 40%.

As an Iranian-American, I am no stranger to hookah. My first hookah “sessions” took place at Persian “mehmoonies,” or parties during my early teenage years; I spent hours at a time sharing stories over fruit-flavored tobacco.

I have also observed a shift in practices of hookah-smoking: no longer a strictly Middle-Eastern practice reserved for special occassions, hookah has become a trendy pastime among the majority of my college-age peers, many of them Caucasian males between the ages of 18 and 24.

Amongst the general trends, it has also been found that hookah is most popular amongst those with some college education as well as those who currently smoke or recently quit cigarettes. These statistics beg the following question: Why would a well-educated group of Americans recently become engaged in an activity with no domestic cultural roots, especially when that activity involves a high amount of health risk? Researchers of the American Lung Association suggest that this recent rise in hookah use is, in part, a consequence of the recent bans on cigarette smoking. Because many people may be using hookah to help them quit cigarettes, it is wrongly adopting a reputation of a “safe” way to get a tobacco fix.

This mistake is often made because hookah smoke passes through water, which some incorrectly perceive to act as an effective filter. But the many contaminants of tobacco remain in the smoke regardless of its passage through water. The charcoal that fuels the hookah also releases carbon monoxide, a toxic gas. Because of these factors, and because hookah smoking sessions last much longer than a cigarette, hookah smoking is a deadly hobby.

Perhaps it is time for young people to realize that hookah does count as smoking. Hookah is associated with all of the same health consequences as cigarette smoke. Smoking bans were implemented to help eliminate these diseases. By replacing cigarettes with hookah we are merely continuing towards a future with an elderly population swarming with lung, bladder, and throat cancers.

Although smoking ban policies primarily aim to protect non-smokers from the health hazards associated with second-hand smoke, many who support the bans also cite discouragement of cigarette use as a benefit of the prohibitory policy. Unfortunately, it appears that smoking bans actually exacerbate the health conditions of some smokers. This is a commonly overlooked fact that should, perhaps, be included in smoking ban discussions in the future.





About the Author

Roxanne Massoumi
Roxanne is a recent graduate from University of California, Irvine, where she studied Biological Science. She currently works as a chemist at Gilead Sciences, a bio-pharmaceutical company headquartered in Foster City, California.




 
 

 
ucsd-divestment2

UC San Diego Student Government calls for divestment from Israeli Occupation

San Diego, CA, March 14, 2013 — After a four year campaign, UCSD’s undergraduate student government has passed a resolution urging the University of California, San Diego to cease its investments in companies that profi...
by Rishi Ghosh
6

 
 
MBA candidates and energy utility employees team up with volunteers from a New York City service agency to paint a theater in the notorious Midtown area white

Keeping it cool: In NYC, volunteers promote urban sustainability

“It’s not every day we get to paint a roof in Midtown,” said Special Projects Manager for the New York City Service Wendy Dessy to a group of volunteers assembled in the basement of the David H. Koch Theater in Lincoln Ce...
by Erin Brodwin
1

 
 
strawberry-heart-pixdaus-com

The Meat and Potatoes of American Health

As I write this, a single piece of legislation with the greatest potential to improve America’s health sits in limbo in our nation’s capital. As soon as a few weeks from today, the government will release its final decision...
by Hideyuki Murakami
0

 

 
spain-recovery

Spain’s Bailout Raises Questions, Reflections

On Saturday, Spain’s Finance Minister Luis de Guindos announced that, in an emergency meeting, Eurozone and other European financial leaders agreed to a €100 billion bailout of private Spanish banks. While Spanish Prime...
by Hideyuki Murakami
1

 
 
Photo by Hassan Sharaf

In the battle for Tahrir, protestors apply lessons learned in January

“If I die, post these to my Facebook,” Moustafa Salah, age 22, said half-jokingly as I photographed him in a fifth-story apartment one block from Tahrir Square in downtown Cairo. He and four friends prepared for their retur...
by Stephanie Figgins
2

 




One Comment


  1. harleyrider1978

    We’ve been told for years secondhand smoke is deadly dangerous but we are here alive and there are no deaths from it, not even close.

    It’s an exaggerated, created science all its own. It’s propaganda – fallacies created to have justifications for a new round of tobacco prohibition. I am for freedom, freedom for all people to have their own place in this world, including the smokers!

    Tobacco smoke maybe an irritant to some, but that’s about it. Its chemical makeup has been so exaggerated by tobacco control pundits, it’s insanity. Only 6 percent of tobacco smoke constitutes those 7,000 theorized and identified components of the smoke. Theorized is the word, since the claimed chemicals are themselves so small they can barely be detected. Nanograms, femtograms are the sizes of what can be detected so they theorize the rest. Four percent is carbon monoxide, while nearly 90 percent constitutes ordinary atmospheric air! These figures come from the surgeon general’s report in 1989.

    Oh the pundits may bring up benzene in tobacco smoke. The average cigarette produces roughly 300 micrograms of benzene (1986 report of the surgeon general. p.130) 0.3 micrograms – 300 nanograms.

    Benzene is normally found in fruits, fish, vegetables, nuts, dairy products, beverages and eggs. The National Cancer Institute estimates that an individual may safely ingest up to 250 micrograms in their food per day, every single day of the year.

    Thus, the “safe” exposure to benzene from one day of a normal diet is roughly equal to the exposure experienced by a nonsmoker sharing an airspace with smokers for over 750 hours.

    It’s a political movement and it was never about health.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>